Skip to main content Caffrey's Tavern Logo
  • Caffrey's Tavern
  • 440 US-9
  • Forked River, NJ 08731
  • (609) 693-6613
CALL US
Return to Main Menu
  • Order Online
  • Home
  • Menu
  • Drink List
  • Specials
  • Weekly Events
  • Catering
  • Photo Gallery
  • Contact Us
  • Directions
  • Caffrey's Backyard
  • Caffrey's Sushi
  • Caffrey's Tavern
  • 440 US-9
  • Forked River, NJ 08731
  • (609) 693-6613
facebook iconinstagram icon
HOURS
Open 7 Days A Week
Starting at 11:00am

Menu

Pre-Game

  • SPINACH DIP8.00

    Served with Chips

  • NACHO PLATTER14.00

    Tortilla Chips Topped with Seasoned Beef and Beans, Cheddar and Monterey Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Jalapeno Peppers, Tomatoes and Black Olives, Served with Salsa and Sour Cream

  • BUFFALO BLAST13.00

    Buffalo Chicken and Cheddar Cheese Eggrolls

  • LOADED POTATO TOTS12.00

    Tots Topped with Bacon, Chives and Cheddar Cheese

  • MOZZARELLA STICKS12.00

    Creamy Mozzarella Coated with a Crispy Batter

  • OUTRAGEOUS ONION12.00

    Large Onion Coated and Deep-Fried Served with a Tangy Russian Horseradish Sauce

  • POT STICKERS9.00

    Deep-Fried and Served with Teriyaki Sauce

  • DRUNKEN CLAMS15.00

    Local clams with garlic, butter, beer, thyme and parsley

  • PRETZEL NUGGETS9.00

    Served with Beer Cheese Sauce

  • CHEESE QUESADILLA10.00

    Stuffed with Cheddar and Monterey Jack

  • CHICKEN QUESADILLA11.00

    Chicken Smothered with Cheddar and Monterey Jack

  • PHILLY CHEESESTEAK QUESADILLA12.00

    With Peppers and Onions

  • BONELESS WINGS14.00

    Toss in One Of Our House Sauces: Buffalo (Mild, Hot or Wow) Honey BBQ Garlic Parmesan General Tso's Korean BBQ

  • PIEROGIES12.00

    Sauteed in Butter and Onions Served with Sour Cream

  • POTATO SKINS8.00

    Stuffed with Cheddar Cheese and Bacon, Served with Sour Cream

  • SWEET POTATO WAFFLE FRIES8.00

    Served with a bourbon dipping sauce

  • SHRIMP YOUR WAY16.00

    Cocktail, Buffalo (Mild, Hot or Wow), Garlic or Coconut

  • CALAMARI16.00

    Served Deep-Fried, Plain, Cajun or Firecracker

  • MUSSELS16.00

    Served Scampi or Marinara with Garlic Bread

  • CHEESE CURD14.00

    Deep-Fried Curd with Dipping Sauce

  • CAFFREY'S WINGS16.00

    10 Wings - with Celery and Blue Cheese Buffalo (Mild, Hot, or Wow) Honey BBQ Garlic Parmesan General Tso's Korean BBQ

  • CHICKEN FINGERS12.00

    Boneless Deep-Fried Chicken Tenders Plain, BBQ or Buffalo (Mild, Hot or Wow)

  • CHEESY MUSHROOMS9.00

    Broiled Mushroom Caps with our Seafood Stuffing

Field of Greens

  • SOUTHWEST SALAD12.00

    Romaine Lettuce, Grilled Corn, Black Beans, Avocado, Grape Tomatoes, Red Onion, Cheddar Cheese

  • GRANNY SMITH12.00

    Mixed Greens, Pecans, Dried Cranberries, Red Onion and Granny Smith Apples, Served with Champagne Vinaigrette

  • TOSTADO SALAD12.00

    Fresh Greens, Diced Tomatoes, Onions, Jalapenos and Melted Mixed Cheese in a Fried Taco Shell

  • SPINACH SALAD12.00

    Spinach, Mushrooms, Bacon, Mandarin Orange and Crumbled Bleu Cheese

  • COBB SALAD12.00

    Mixed Greens, Olives, Tomatoes, Eggs, Onion, Bacon and Crumbled Bleu Cheese

  • GREEK SALAD12.00

    Mixed Greens, Red Peppers, Red Onion, Greek Olives and Feta Cheese

  • CAESAR SALAD12.00

    Romaine Tossed with Croutons and Creamy Caesar

  • PECAN SALAD12.00

    Romaine, Dried Cranberries, Pecans and Crumbled Bleu Cheese

  • QUINOA SALAD13.00

    Quinoa, Avocado, Red Onion, Hard Boiled Eggs, Grilled Corn and Black Beans

  • BERRY'S FIELD SALAS13.00

    Arugula, Blueberries, Strawberries, Goat Cheese, Pecans and Almonds served with a Champagne Vinaigrette

  • ADD A PROTEIN TO YOUR SALAD

    Grilled Chicken + $4 | Steak + $12 | Grilled Tuna + $15 | Calamari + $7 | Pecan Crusted Chicken + $5 | Grilled Shrimp + $8 | Coconut Shrimp + $8 | Crab Cake + $15 | Pepper Tuna + $15 | Chicken Salad + $3 | Salmon + $9 | Tuna Salad + $3

Super Bowls

  • SOUP OF THE DAY

    Our Chef's Choice
    Cup $4 | Bowl $7

  • CROCK OF CHILI8.00

    *SPICY* Our Homemade Chili Topped with Raw Onions and Cheddar Cheese

  • CROCK OF FRENCH ONION SOUP7.00

    Topped with Croutons, Swiss and Muenster Cheese

  • CRAB CORN CHOWDER9.00

The Main Event

  • Served with Soup or Salad and Choice of Potato (Unless Otherwise Noted)

  • CHICKEN CAFFREY'S22.00

    Hot and Sweet Peppers, Onions, Mushrooms and Potatoes Sauteed in Our Famous Garlic and Vinaigrette Sauce

  • PENNE A LA VODKA16.00

    Penne Pasta Tossed in Our Creamy Pink Vodka Sauce
    with Chicken $18 | with Shrimp $22

  • VEAL OSSO BUCO36.00

    eal Shank braised in in mushroom and sherry wine sauce, served over mashed potatoes

  • CHICKEN CORDON BLEU32.00

    Breaded chicken breast stuffed with imported ham and Swiss with a creamy Alfredo sauce, served with a choice of potato

  • CHICKEN FRANCAISE OR MARSALA22.00

    Served Over Linguine

  • CHICKEN PARMIGIANA21.00

    Lightly Breaded and Baked with Marinara and Mozzarella Cheese, Served over Linguine

  • CORNED BEEF AND CABBAGE24.00

    Sliced Corned Beef, Cabbage and Potatoes Steamed in Beer

  • SURF AND TURF RAVIOLIS26.00

    3 beef short rib raviolis and 3 lobster raviolis served in a sherry lobster cream sauce

  • FISH AND CHIPS24.00

    Served with fresh kettle chips and tartar sauce

  • SUB CROCK OF ONION SOUP4.00

    CHANGE YOUR SOUP OF THE DAY FOR A CROCK OF ONION SOUP WITH A DINNER FOR AN UPCHARGE

Steak Your Claim

  • All Flame Grilled Steaks Served with Soup or Salad and Choice of Potato

  • NEW YORK SIRLOIN STEAK

    Flame Grilled Sirloin Steak Topped with Onion Rings
    8 oz $27 | 14 oz $38

  • BLACK AND BLEU STEAK39.00

    16 oz NY Strip Steak Grilled with Cajun Spices Finished with Crumbled Bleu Cheese

  • FILET OSCAR47.00

    Filet Mignon Topped with Lump Crabmeat, Asparagus and Hollandaise Sauce
    Plain grilled filet with onion strings $36

  • FLAT IRON STEAK36.00

    Our Grilled 14 oz Flat Iron Steak with Mushrooms, Onions and Spicy Bourbon Sauce

  • PORTERHOUSE PORK CHOP24.00

    Grilled Porterhouse Pork Chop Finished with Creole Mustard Butter Sauce

  • CAFFREY'S RIB EYE35.00

    12 oz Flame Grilled Rib Eye Served with Sauteed Mushrooms and Onions

  • PLAIN FILET39.00

Hook, Line and Sinker

  • Served with Soup or Salad and Choice of Potato (Unless Otherwise Noted)

  • CAFFREY'S CRAB CAKE39.00

    Fresh Maryland Lump Crab Meat made into Delicious Cakes with Remoulade Sauce

  • SEAFOOD FRA DIABLO31.00

    *SPICY* Shrimp, Mussels, Calamari and Scallops Served over Linguine

  • SEAFOOD SCAMPI31.00

    Shrimp, Mussels, Calamari and Scallops Served over Linguine

  • BROILED SALMON28.00

    Grilled Salmon Fillet with Your Choice of Thai Chili or Sesame Sauce

  • SHRIMP FETTUCCINI24.00

    Sauteed Shrimp with Mushrooms and Sun-dried Tomatoes in a Garlic Basil Cream Sauce Tossed with Fettuccini

  • COCONUT SHRIMP26.00

    Deep-fried Coconut Crusted Shrimp

  • GRILLED TUNA26.00

    Sushi Grade Tuna Grilled and Finished with a Roasted Pepper, Garlic and Basil Sauce

Grilled Supremacy

  • Served with Soup or Salad and Choice of Potato

  • STEAK AND RIBS32.00

    8 oz Flat Iron Steak Served with a Portion of Flame grilled BBQ Baby Back Ribs

  • SHRIMP AND RIBS29.00

    Fried or Stuffed Shrimp with a Portion of Flame Grilled BBQ Baby Back Ribs

  • BABY BACK RIBS26.00

    Flame Grilled Baby Back Ribs in our Tangy BBQ Sauce

  • BREAST OF CHICKEN16.00

    Flame Grilled in a Tangy BBQ Sauce

  • CHICKEN AND RIBS26.00

    A Single BBQ Chicken Breast Served with our Flame Grilled BBQ Baby Back Ribs

  • STEAK AND SHRIMP32.00

    8 oz Flat Iron Steak Grilled with Deep-fried or Stuffed Shrimp

Meat of The Order

  • Flame Grilled Burgers Served with Fries

  • CAFFREY'S HAMBURGER13.00

    8 oz Flame Grilled Burger
    Add cheese $2 | California style $2 | Add bacon $2

  • BLACKJACK BURGER16.00

    Grilled in Cajun Spices with Sauteed Onions and Cheddar Cheese

  • SMOTHERED BURGER16.00

    Topped with Swiss Cheese, Sauteed Peppers and Onions

  • GARBAGE CAN17.00

    Topped with Pork Roll and American Cheese

  • NO BURGER16.00

    Our Meatless Burger Served California Style

  • WAKE-UP BURGER17.00

    Our Burger with Sausage Patty, Fried Egg, and American Cheese

  • KCL BURGER16.00

    Topped with Bacon, BBQ Sauce, Onion Rings and American Cheese

  • BOURBON BURGER16.00

    Our grilled burger topped with bacon, provolone cheese, onion strings and bourbon sauce served with a pretzel roll

  • PATTI MELT15.00

    Served with Sauteed Onions and Swiss cheese on Grilled Rye

Hot Corner

  • Served with French Fries, Slaw and Pickle (Unless Otherwise Noted)

  • CAFFREY'S CHEESESTEAK14.00

    Sliced Steak or Chicken with Peppers, Onions and Cheese on a Hoagie Roll

  • NASHVILLE HOT CHICKEN SANDWICH15.00

    Crispy chicken, shredded cabbage, pickle chips and Nashville hot sauce.

  • PORK ROLL AND CHEESE10.00

    That Old Time Favorite on a Hard Roll

  • OPEN FACED REUBEN14.00

    Lean Corned Beef Served on Grilled Rye, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese and Russian Dressing

  • HOT ROAST BEEF SANDWICH14.00

    Served with Mashed Potatoes, Gravy and Vegetables

  • HOT TURKEY SANDWICH14.00

    Served with Mashed Potatoes, Gravy and Vegetables

  • GRILLED CHICKEN SANDWICH14.00

    Served Plain, BBQ, Buffalo (Mild, Hot or Wow), Cajun or Honey Mustard

  • PUB CHICKEN SANDWICH16.00

    Beer battered chicken breast topped with bacon and beer cheese sauce served on a pretzel bun

  • FRESH CRAB CAKE SANDWICH20.00

    Homemade Maryland Lump Crab Cake on an English Muffin with Lettuce, Tomato and Tartar Sauce

  • FRIED COD SANDWICH16.00

    Deep-Fried Cod Served on a Hoagie Roll with Chopped Lettuce and Tomatoes

  • FRENCH DIP15.00

    Sliced roast beef, fried onions and Swiss on garlic bread served with Au Jus

  • PO' BOY SHRIMP16.00

    Fried shrimp, shredded cabbage, tomatoes and a sriracha and mayo sauce served on a hoagie roll

Deli Delights

  • Choice of Bread:

    White, Rye, Whole Wheat or Hard Roll Served with Chips, Slaw and Pickle

  • Choice of:

    Chipotle Mayo, Wasabi Mayo, Avocado and Ranch Mayo, or Horseradish

  • HAM AND CHEESE12.00

  • TURKEY BREAST12.00

  • ROAST BEEF12.00

  • HOT CORN BEEF12.00

  • HOT PASTRAMI12.00

  • BLT12.00

  • TUNA SALAD12.00

  • CHICKEN SALAD12.00

  • Club It Up!3.00

    Turn Any Deli Sandwich into A Club

Wrap It Up

  • Wrapped in a Flour Tortilla Served with French Fries

  • CHICKEN FINGER CALIFORNIA15.00

    Deep-Fried Chicken Tenders, Lettuce, Tomato and Onion Served with Side of Mayo

  • TURKEY CLUB WRAP15.00

    Sliced Turkey, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onion and Bacon Served with Side of Mayo

  • BUFFALO CHICKEN CAESAR15.00

    Deep-Fried Chicken Tenders Tossed in Buffalo Sauce with Romaine Lettuce and Caesar Dressing

  • CHICKEN FAJITA16.00

    Grilled Chicken, Peppers, Onions and Fajita Sauce

  • CHEESESTEAK WRAP15.00

    Shredded Steak or Chicken with Peppers, Onions and American Cheese

  • CAJUN CHICKEN CAESAR15.00

    Seasoned Grilled Cajun Chicken, Romaine Lettuce And Caesar Dressing

Pizza Parlor

  • BAR PIE12.00

    ADD A TOPPING

  • LARGE PIE18.00

    ADD A TOPPING

  • 24" FAMILY PIE30.00

    ADD A TOPPING

  • BUFFALO CHICKEN PIZZA

    Served with Spicy Buffalo Chicken
    Bar Pie $16 | Large Pie $20

  • BROCCOLI RABE PIZZA

    Topped with Broccoli Rabe, Garlic, Smoked Mozzarella, Ricotta Cheese
    Bar Pie $16 | Large Pie $20

  • WHITE PIE

    Topped with Ricotta, Mozzarella and Romano Cheese
    Bar Pie $15 | Large Pie $19

  • CHEESESTEAK PIE

    Shredded Steak, Peppers, Onions and Cheddar Cheese
    Bar Pie $18 | Large Pie $22

  • SHRIMP SCAMPI PIE

    Sauteed Shrimp, Garlic and Herbs
    Bar Pie $17 | Large Pie $22

  • VEGETARIAN PIE

    Tomatoes, Onions, Mushrooms, Peppers and Onions
    Bar Pie $14 | Large Pie $18

  • MARGHERITA PIE

    Chopped Tomatoes, Garlic, Basil, Olive Oil and Fresh Mozzarella
    Bar Pie $16 | Large Pie $20

  • BACON AND VODKA SAUCE PIE

    Thin Crust, Homemade Vodka Sauce, Mozzarella and Bacon
    Bar Pie $16 | Large Pie $20

  • Toppings Include:

    Onions | Olives | Peppers | Extra Cheese | Pepperoni | Sausage | Tomatoes | Mushrooms | Broccoli | Bacon | Pineapple | Ham | Meatballs

Soft Tacos

  • Served with French Fries

  • GRILLED SHRIMP TACOS17.00

    with pico de Gallo

  • TUNA POKE TACOS18.00

    Sushi Grade Tuna with Soy Sauce, Scallions, Cilantro and Avocado, Served with Pico de Gallo and French Fries

  • STEAK TACOS17.00

    Grilled Flank Steak, Raw Onion, Cilantro and Salsa Served with French Fries

Flatbreads

  • GRILLED CHICKEN PESTO12.00

    Sun-dried Tomato Pesto on Flatbread Topped with Grilled Chicken, Roasted Pepper and Goat Cheese

  • THE ITALIANO14.00

    Fresh Tomatoes, Roasted Red Peppers, Basil, Prosciutto, Mozzarella and Balsamic Glaze

  • O'REILLY FLAT BREAD14.00

    Grilled flat bread topped with figs, blue cheese and balsamic glaze

Little Leaguers

  • 10 and Under

    Includes Fountain Soda, Juice or Milk and Ice Cream

  • HOT DOG8.00

    Served with French Fries

  • HAMBURGER8.00

    Served with French Fries

  • CHEESEBURGER8.00

    Served with French Fries

  • GRILLED CHEESE8.00

    Served with French Fries

  • CHICKEN NUGGETS8.00

    Served with French Fries

  • MACARONI AND CHEESE8.00

  • KIDS TRIO8.00

    Mozzarella Sticks, Chicken Fingers and French Fries

  • PASTA WITH MARINARA8.00

Items and pricing subject to change without notice.
This notice is provided for Website Accessibility best practices
You are leaving caffreystavern.com
We are redirecting you to...
Website accessibility, security and privacy policies may be different than ours.
Close Notice Continue to Website
Web Design © Restaurant Passion, Inc.